The best underlayment for shingles is synthetic or rubberized asphalt. These materials protect your roof better than old felt paper. They stop water leaks and last longer.
Synthetic underlayment is lighter and easier to install. It does not tear as easy as felt paper. Many roofers pick synthetic because it works well in cold and hot weather.
Rubberized asphalt underlayment is sticky and self-adhesive. It sticks to your roof deck on its own. This type works great for ice dams in cold areas.
Synthetic Underlayment for Shingles
Synthetic underlayment is made from plastic and fibers. It does not rot or fall apart like felt paper does. According to industry data, synthetic underlayment lasts 15 to 20 years under shingles.
This material is light and strong. Roofers can work faster with synthetic underlayment. It does not slip on your roof deck.
Synthetic shingle underlayment costs more upfront. But it saves money later because it lasts so long. You will not need to replace it as often as felt paper.
Related articles:
- What Is the Best Time of Year to Replace a Roof
- How Many Bundles of Shingles for a 2000 Sq Ft Roof
- How Much Do Roofers Charge to Install Shingles
- Can I Estimate Shingles Myself
Rubberized Asphalt Underlayment
Rubberized asphalt is sticky on one side. You peel off the back and stick it down. It seals itself as your shingles press on top.
This type works best in cold climates. The rubber stays flexible when it freezes. It stops ice dams from tearing up your roof.
Rubberized asphalt costs between $50 to $100 per square for labor and materials. Recent studies show that homeowners in snowy areas pick rubberized asphalt 60 percent of the time. One square covers 100 square feet of roof.
Felt Paper Underlayment
Felt paper is the oldest type of underlayment. It is cheap and has been used for many years. But it falls apart faster than new materials.
Felt paper absorbs water and can rot. It gets slippery when wet. Roofers slip more on felt paper than synthetic.
Most roofers no longer use felt paper for new roofs. Insurance industry data indicates that only 15 percent of new roofs use felt paper today. It is mostly used for repairs on old roofs.
How to Pick the Right Underlayment
Think about your climate first. Cold areas need rubberized asphalt. Warm, dry areas can use synthetic underlayment.
Check your roof deck next. Old wood decks work with felt paper or synthetic. New plywood decks work best with synthetic or rubberized asphalt.
Your budget matters too. Here are the main types and costs:
| Underlayment Type | Cost Per Square | Lifespan | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| Felt Paper | $15-$25 | 5-10 years | Old roofs |
| Synthetic | $40-$80 | 15-20 years | Most climates |
| Rubberized Asphalt | $50-$100 | 20+ years | Cold areas |
Related articles:
Best Practices for Shingle Underlayment
Always overlap your underlayment from bottom to top. Water runs down, so top pieces must cover bottom pieces. Nail or staple it every 6 to 8 inches.
According to the National Roofing Contractors Association, proper installation of underlayment prevents 90 percent of water leaks. Bad installation causes most roof failures, not bad materials. Take time to do it right.
Do not stretch underlayment too tight. It needs room to move in hot and cold weather. Leave small gaps at edges and corners.
Why Underlayment Matters Under Shingles
Shingles are the top layer of your roof. But underlayment is the real protection. It catches water that gets under your shingles.
Water always finds small holes and cracks. Wind can lift shingles up. Rain blows sideways under them. Underlayment stops that water before it hits your home.
HomeAdvisor reports that poor underlayment causes 25 percent of roof leaks. Many roofs fail because people pick cheap underlayment to save money. Then leaks cost thousands to fix inside the house.
Key points about underlayment for shingles:
- Synthetic underlayment is best for most homes today
- Rubberized asphalt is best for cold climates with ice dams
- Felt paper is old and not recommended for new roofs
- Proper installation matters more than the brand
- Quality underlayment adds only $200 to $400 to total roof cost
Common Underlayment Mistakes
Many people install underlayment wrong. They do not overlap it enough. They stretch it too tight.
Some roofers skip underlayment to save money. This is a big mistake. Roofing insurance claims show that 1 out of every 4 claims happen because of bad underlayment.
Do not mix different types of underlayment on one roof. Stick with one type from start to finish. Different materials have different expansion rates and can cause problems where they meet.
Connect with an experienced roof contractor to discuss your roofing needs and schedule an inspection.